Hotel prices / United States / Sanibel Island
Sanibel Island hotel price comparison: 14 hotels across booking sites
14 Sanibel Island hotels, each priced on every booking site we recorded for it. Prices on this page are per night, all-in where the sites reported taxes and fees; the study's count below uses the before-tax prices of its CSV. The going rate is the price the largest number of listings that named a room or offered free cancellation agreed on (ties go to the lower price).
One snapshot on October 1, 2026 for Nov 5 to Nov 7, 2 adults, US market, USD. Prices change daily.
Which booking site was cheapest for Sanibel Island hotels?
The study's count, before taxes and fees: in the October 1, 2026 snapshot, at 9 of the 14 Sanibel Island hotels with a price, the cheapest listing was 5% or more below the going rate. The cheapest site there: Super.com at 2, Agoda at 1, Evendo at 1, Hotels In America at 1, Hotels.com at 1, KAYAK.com at 1, Reservation Day at 1 and Traveluro at 1. These are the Sanibel Island rows of the study's per-hotel CSV (going_rate_usd and cheapest_usd, before taxes and fees).
On this page, all-in: with taxes and fees included as the sites reported them, at 8 of the 14 hotels listed below a site was 5% or more below the all-in going rate. The cheapest site there: Super.com at 2, Agoda at 1, Etrip.net at 1, Evendo at 1, goseek.com at 1, Hotels In America at 1, Hotels.com at 1, Reservation Day at 1 and 1 other site at 1 between them (a tie counts for each site). At the other 6, no site was 5% or more below it. The two counts differ: at 1 of the hotels listed below, the all-in prices put the gap on the other side of the 5% line. Each hotel below shows every site's all-in price. Across all cities: the cheapest site to book hotels, measured.
- 'Tween Waters Inn & Marina
No site 5% or more below the going rate of $283. 16 sites.
- Anchor Inn & Cottages Newly Remodeled
Lowest $195 on Hotels.com, 6% below the going rate of $207. 13 sites.
- Casa Ybel Beach Resort
No site 5% or more below the going rate of $321. 9 sites.
- La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Ft. Myers-Sanibel Gateway
No site 5% or more below the going rate of $115. 8 sites.
- Latitude 26 Waterfront Boutique Resort - Fort Myers Beach
No site 5% or more below the going rate of $148. 17 sites.
- Latitude 26 Waterfront Resort and Marina - Fort Myers Beach
Lowest $135 on Agoda, 21% below the going rate of $170. 9 sites.
- Lighthouse Island Resort
Lowest $126 on Super.com, 24% below the going rate of $165. 18 sites.
- Marriott Sanibel Harbour Resort & Spa
No site 5% or more below the going rate of $293. 19 sites.
- Pink Shell Beach Resort & Marina
Lowest $490 on Hotels In America, 16% below the going rate of $585. 12 sites.
- Residence Inn by Marriott Fort Myers Sanibel
Lowest $114 on Evendo, 32% below the going rate of $167. 10 sites.
- Sanibel Island Beach Resort
Lowest $204 on Super.com, 27% below the going rate of $278. 24 sites.
- South Seas
Lowest $270 on goseek.com, Vio.com and Etrip.net, 33% below the going rate of $404. 27 sites.
- Sundial Beach Resort & Spa
Lowest $394 on Reservation Day, 24% below the going rate of $521. 23 sites.
- Sunshine Island Inn
No site 5% or more below the going rate of $233. 3 sites.
More US cities we priced
Every city we priced in the United States. Its hotels by star class: 5-star · 4-star · 3-star · 1- and 2-star · No star class listed.