Hotel prices / United States / Sanibel Island
Sanibel Island hotel price comparison: 14 hotels across booking sites
This snapshot was for a stay that has passed.
Prices for the stay of Nov 5 to 7, 2026, as listed on October 1, 2026.
14 Sanibel Island hotels, each priced on every booking site we recorded for it. Prices on this page are per night, all-in where the sites reported taxes and fees; the study's count below uses the before-tax prices of its CSV. The going rate is the price the largest number of listings that named a room or offered free cancellation agreed on (ties go to the lower price).
One snapshot on October 1, 2026 for Nov 5 to Nov 7, 2 adults, US market, USD. Prices change daily.
Which booking site was cheapest for Sanibel Island hotels?
The study's count, before taxes and fees: in the October 1, 2026 snapshot, at 9 of the 14 Sanibel Island hotels with a price, the cheapest listing was 5% or more below the going rate. The cheapest site there: Super.com at 2, Agoda at 1, Evendo at 1, Hotels In America at 1, Hotels.com at 1, KAYAK.com at 1, Reservation Day at 1 and Traveluro at 1. These are the Sanibel Island rows of the study's per-hotel CSV (going_rate_usd and cheapest_usd, before taxes and fees).
On this page, all-in: with taxes and fees included as the sites reported them, at 8 of the 14 hotels listed below a site was 5% or more below the all-in going rate. The cheapest site there: Super.com at 2, Agoda at 1, Etrip.net at 1, Evendo at 1, goseek.com at 1, Hotels In America at 1, Hotels.com at 1, Reservation Day at 1 and 1 other site at 1 between them (a tie counts for each site). At the other 6, no site was 5% or more below it. The two counts differ: at 1 of the hotels listed below, the all-in prices put the gap on the other side of the 5% line. Each hotel below shows every site's all-in price. Across all cities: the cheapest site to book hotels, measured.
- 'Tween Waters Inn & Marina
No site 5% or more below the going rate of $283. 16 sites.
- Anchor Inn & Cottages Newly Remodeled
Lowest $195 on Hotels.com, 6% below the going rate of $207. 13 sites.
- Casa Ybel Beach Resort
No site 5% or more below the going rate of $321. 9 sites.
- La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Ft. Myers-Sanibel Gateway
No site 5% or more below the going rate of $115. 8 sites.
- Latitude 26 Waterfront Boutique Resort - Fort Myers Beach
No site 5% or more below the going rate of $148. 17 sites.
- Latitude 26 Waterfront Resort and Marina - Fort Myers Beach
Lowest $135 on Agoda, 21% below the going rate of $170. 9 sites.
- Lighthouse Island Resort
Lowest $126 on Super.com, 24% below the going rate of $165. 18 sites.
- Marriott Sanibel Harbour Resort & Spa
No site 5% or more below the going rate of $293. 19 sites.
- Pink Shell Beach Resort & Marina
Lowest $490 on Hotels In America, 16% below the going rate of $585. 12 sites.
- Residence Inn by Marriott Fort Myers Sanibel
Lowest $114 on Evendo, 32% below the going rate of $167. 10 sites.
- Sanibel Island Beach Resort
Lowest $204 on Super.com, 27% below the going rate of $278. 24 sites.
- South Seas
Lowest $270 on goseek.com, Vio.com and Etrip.net, 33% below the going rate of $404. 27 sites.
- Sundial Beach Resort & Spa
Lowest $394 on Reservation Day, 24% below the going rate of $521. 23 sites.
- Sunshine Island Inn
No site 5% or more below the going rate of $233. 3 sites.
Taxes and fees at Sanibel Island hotels
At the 7 hotels with both an all-in and a before-tax going rate, taxes and fees, as the booking sites reported them to Google Hotels, added a median of 11% ($29 a night) to the before-tax going rate: from 11% at Latitude 26 Waterfront Boutique Resort - Fort Myers Beach to 12% at Anchor Inn & Cottages Newly Remodeled. At 7 hotels no site reported a before-tax price, so their prices are listed prices that may leave out resort or property fees. Our data does not split the gap into taxes and fees.
More US cities we priced
Every city we priced in the United States. Its hotels by star class: 5-star · 4-star · 3-star · 1- and 2-star · No star class listed.